this the second the second thing I want
to address is the whole thing about
negative and positive you know this is
too important to be a word game but any
clown knows that something is positive
to one person is negative to the other
be nuts that's just a simple matter of
language of semantics so begin you find
you're arguing for a no there's an
element of negativity because in the
what what no is negative but if you look
at the things that I'm arguing for and
George's arguing for incredibly positive
about them I'm incredibly positive about
every force within society that has
given me my life opportunities I'm
incredibly positive with the National
Health Service a bit comprehensive
education about slump Liam's about a
welfare state every one of which has
been built through struggle and I said
the advantage of not only benefiting
people in Scotland but in every part of
a united kingdom and in contrast to my
positivity about all of these things I
can think of nothing more negative but
to divide a small island in two separate
states in the 21st second decade of the
21st century that is what is negative so
forget the positives and negatives this
is a positive campaign in favor of
values in favor of unity and favour of
the things we've done together over the
years and the negativity is to divide us
by a border there would be a border
there would be a border it is divided us
by a border on the basis of identity and
George use the example of Liverpool let
me tell you nobody will ever persuade me
that Liverpudlians are foreigners nobody
will ever persuade me of that and if it
and if we try to argue that case in any
part of west of the west of Scotland
just two or three weeks ago I think
they'd have got a very very dusty reply